Sacha Kljestan’s Red Card Upheld by Independent Review Panel

Sacha Kljestan

HARRISON, N.J. (November 16, 2017) – Major League Soccer announced today that the Independent Review Panel, the ruling body for player appeals, has denied the appeal for the red card issued to New York’s Sacha Kljestan during the second leg of the Eastern Conference Semifinal in Toronto on November 5. The panel also denied Toronto FC’s appeal of Jozy Altidore’s red card from the same match. 


New York won the match, 1-0, but lost the series on the away goals tiebreaker after a 2-2 aggregate draw. 


The Independent Panel consists of one representative from the U.S. Soccer Federation, one representative from the Canadian Soccer Association and one representative from the Professional Referees Organization (PRO).

2026 Season Tickets On Sale Now!

2026 Season Tickets On Sale Now!

From upgraded game day experiences and exclusive events, to the unforgettable moments leading into the biggest year in soccer, there’s never been a better time to be part of our community!

Score The App and Kick the Lines on Matchday

Score The App and Kick the Lines on Matchday

Download the new and improved Red Bull New York app to stay up to date on all things RBNY and access your tickets to Sports Illustrated Stadium.